When I was looking for dead sea salt scrub, this question cropped up in my mind. ‘Who will be next year’s AI judge?’ Since the American Idol 2011 season has ended, there must be a lot of speculation on whether this year’s new judges did their jobs well, if not, whether they will be replaced, and who will it be?
What do you think? I think Steven Tyler is a great singer, but no doubt he sucked as an AI judge. He doesn’t provide advice to the contestants like Simon does. Everything he says are based on what other judges has commented, and it is too positive.
J.Lo on the other hand is slightly better than Steven, but still not up to standard at all. I feel that they did a good job at encouraging the contestants, but did not give them contructive critism and advice. The best is still Randy out of all 3. That is my oppinion anyway. What do you think ?


